The Pittsburgh Steelers welcomed two capable starting quarterbacks in the 2024 offseason in Russell Wilson and Justin Fields. Wilson was named the starter, but a calf injury sidelined him for six games. In Wilson’s absence, Fields stepped up admirably, leading the team to a 4-2 record while delivering solid performances at quarterback. Fields’ success on the field made him a fan favorite, raising questions about who should start once Wilson recovered.

Despite Fields’ strong play, Head Coach Mike Tomlin made the surprising decision to reinstate Wilson as the starter upon his return. Though unpopular initially, Tomlin’s choice has been validated, as Wilson has led the team with two consecutive wins. However, the decision also hints at a larger question the Steelers face about their future at quarterback—one that may have significant financial and strategic implications for the team.

With both Wilson and Fields set to become more costly after the season, the Steelers are unlikely to retain both at a high price. Steelers insider Ray Fittipaldo recently shared his insight on 93.7 The Fan, suggesting the organization will likely commit to just one quarterback after the 2024 season. Whether that will be Wilson or Fields remains uncertain, but the Steelers’ offseason decision will undoubtedly shape the team’s path for years to come.

Fittipaldo was asked whether the Steelers would sign Fields to an extension after the season. He responded bluntly, stating that the Steelers would not be bringing Fields back in his opinion.

When the conversation turned to Wilson, Fittipaldo expressed confidence that the team would likely extend him. This isn’t as surprising as it may seem; since the Steelers acquired Wilson, there has been a clear plan to evaluate his performance in 2024 before potentially negotiating a cost-effective extension.

Steelers Are Running A Huge Risk At Quarterback After The 2024 Season

However, this strategy does come with challenges. Despite Wilson’s impressive play, he is set to turn 36 years old in November, meaning he may only have three to four productive years left, with an uncertain duration for his prime. Compounding the issue is Wilson’s recent calf injury, which has already sidelined him for six games this season. In stark contrast, Fields is only 25 years old, presenting the Steelers with a tempting long-term option if they choose to pivot in their quarterback strategy.

Fields has the potential to be the future of the franchise for well over a decade, and the Steelers would be taking a significant risk by giving up on what could be a long-term solution at quarterback. It’s widely understood that quarterbacks over the age of 35 often find themselves in a state of quarterback purgatory, where they lack a clear future and their performance is often not at an elite level.

Insiders are generally optimistic that Wilson will receive a new deal with the Steelers after the season, but this raises important questions about Fields’ future. Some believe Fields has played well enough to earn a lucrative contract elsewhere, where he could take on a starting role. Both quarterbacks have handled the challenging situation with professionalism and grace, making it easier for the Steelers to navigate the ongoing quarterback drama.

Both Wilson and Fields are clearly fan favorites in Steel City, with supporters passionately backing each player. Now, it’s up to the organization to make the best possible choice for the future of the black and gold, ensuring that they secure a quarterback who can lead the team for years to come.